Photo of the Day
Photo of the Day Podcast
Photo of the Day
3
0:00
-4:26

Photo of the Day

No. 608
3

the witness tree

The Sickle Witness Tree, a white swamp oak. [Gettysburg Daily photo]

The weather in Gettysburg was warm on July 2, 1863.

By early afternoon, the temperature was in the low 80s.

So, Daniel Sickles, the commander of a Union force of more than ten thousand men, set up his field headquarters beneath this tree on Peter Trostle’s farm.

The tree was then seventy-five years old and of good size.

Its shade offered a welcome respite from the damp heat wafting across the open farm fields.

Rain was coming.

[Gettysburg Daily photo]

Fighting had broken out in Gettysburg on the day before and more heavy action was expected.

General Meade, the commander of the Army of the Potomac, had ordered Sickles to maintain a defensive position at the farm.

A contemporaneous drawing of Sickles and his staff beneath the tree.

But when Sickles arrived there, he saw a peach orchard 7/10th of a mile away.

He became convinced that the orchard’s higher ground would provide a more favorable position for his men.

Sickles consulted with his staff beneath the tree, then decided to advance into the orchard.

Doing so would violate Meade’s order, but he nevertheless ordered his men to advance.

But it was a fatal mistake.

The advance left Sickles’s men exposed to Confederate attack on two sides, and their line was stretched thin.

Contemporaneous drawing of Sickles’s advance to the peach orchard.

Confederate General James Longstreet assaulted Sickles’s men in fighting which would prove to be one of the most intense confrontations in the three-day Battle of Gettysburg.

And it was a rout.

Sickles’s force was driven back to its original position.

Forty percent of his men had been killed or wounded in the retreat.

Dead horses used by artillery units litter the area surrounding the Trostle farmhouse.

As Sickles, mounted on his horse, watched the battle unfold, a Confederate artillery shell shattered his leg.

It would be amputated.

Sickles would never again command men on a battlefield.

[Gettysburg Daily photo]

This old oak tree withstood it all, bearing silent witness to hubris and suffering beyond imagination.

And, for years afterwards, people would come to Trostle’s Farm, stand beneath this tree, and try to make sense of it all.

The Trostle barn, then and now.

In 1886, Sickles would come back to this place to defend his insubordination.

General Sickles, center, at Trostle’s Farm, 1886.

Historians still debate that day in the peach orchard.

And now, the old tree is the lone survivor of the conflagration.

Painting depicting Sickles’s advance into the peach orchard.

Eighty years after the battle, the poet Robert Frost had this to say.

And off this corner in the wild,
Where these are driven in and piled,
One tree, by being deeply wounded,
Has been impressed as Witness Tree
And made commit to memory
My proof of being not unbounded.
Thus truth’s established and borne out
Though circumstanced with dark and doubt --
Though by a world of doubt surround.

******************************

I’ll see you tomorrow.

- Brenda

Share

Leave a comment

3 Comments
Photo of the Day
Photo of the Day Podcast
A little history.
Listen on
Substack App
Spotify
RSS Feed
Appears in episode
Brenda Elthon